Discussion about this post

User's avatar
3musesmerge's avatar

Going Circular… Another documentary on the same subject: https://curiositystream.com/goingcircular/index.html?utm_source=social&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=startgoingcircular+link+Going+Circular+landing+page&utm_id=startgoingcircular+link+Going+Circular+landing+page

It is on Curiosity Stream… a subscription service. The muses are discussing the merits of signing up. Seems unanimous that 2.99/month is a small price to pay for creative work that drives possibility instead of fear.

Expand full comment
Gary Spangler's avatar

You threw this old dog a tough bone to chew on with today’s BFN! Let me put on my liberal, snowflake hat and ask if there is general agreement, in the linear model, that extinction of species is simply collateral damage that does, and must occur, for a “ healthy” economy. Now, wearing my linear businessman attire, I ask if the fad for electric vehicles and their lithium batteries, warrants the destruction of natural features around the world. Are oil rigs providing the materials for refining gas for our cars that much more obtrusive than windmills in the Atlantic off Nantucket??

Arguing either position convincingly requires value judgements by all parties. Am I grateful for the linear processes that gave rise to the 3-D printers that produced components for my back surgery last week? Yes. Could other methodologies, possibly circularly derived, have also provided relief? I don’t have that answer.

For me notions of sentient beings (like all living things, plants, etc.) has to play a dominant role. While we devastate major ecosystems on our planet, we feign concern for our home by developing a system that might launch a rocket to intercept approaching giant “heavenly bodies.” Irony intentional. Otherwise we will have the fate of dinosaurs and other species that became extinct after a previous impact event. The linear rocket boys have been quite adept at missing production targets and budgets, so that’s of little comfort for earth’s survival in such an instance. Would a circular process fare much better? Unknown.

What do I favor? Stop the Rocket Man business, and love one another! And this planet!

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts